Baking like an American

Countrymen, I royally, revolutionarily screwed up during my annual 4th of July baking spree. Each year, I spend that holiday of holidays cheerfully putting something delicious together for my friend Emily’s annual party. I enjoy the prep, I enjoy the party, I enjoy watching fireworks, and I enjoy thinking about the Founding Fathers.

This year, I’ve figured out something I don’t enjoy: being tricked into crafting when I want to be baking.


Martha’s July issue featured a bunch of cheerfully iced sugar cookies. “Show your colors!” it demanded, and I stupidly complied. My colors are red, white, and blue, just like everybody else’s, only I am best when I display them as raspberries and blueberries scattered across meringue or something.

But no, noooo. I had to try my hand at “edible painting,” which instilled within me a hatred of baking that lasted for a full week. I should have sensed danger when I read the ingredient list, which included “meringue powder” and “icings with special branded color names.”

Mixing up some "Frustrating Red"

I’m never getting food at a craft store again. So gross. First of all, the sugar cookies, while easy enough to make, tasted like big, bland poker chips. But that’s OK. The appeal for these babies is in the beautiful patriotic pinwheels on the top, which are just so, so precious that everyone will overlook the fact that they are eating chemicals that taste like…chemicals.

Well, not if your pinwheels look like they were the end result of an afternoon volunteering at your kid’s preschool, which is exactly what mine looked like. Only I don’t have kids, and now I’m seriously concerned about my future ability to deal with finger paint all over my house.

Unpatriotic BS

The problem lay in the consistency of the icing, which was too thick to work in the squeeze bottles they suggested. So I messily switched to pastry bags with tiny tips, figured out they were also inadequate because of the icing’s consistency. I thinned it down as best I could, used the stuff I had left after the bags and squeeze bottles were rejected, got out new bags, filled them again, bemoaned my stained hands/countertops/baking-reputation, and watched in horror as my fireworks turned into knobbly, stupid messes.

Verdict: Edible Craft Unworthy

This recipe is simply not worth it. By the time I sort of got the hang of it, I was out of icing and thoroughly steamed. And when I tasted one of the ones I had done and discovered how disgusting they were, the top of my head almost blew off with a firework display that would have had no trouble showing anyone my damn colors.

They may look passable in the picture, but the frosting never set up (commenters on believe there is an issue with the recipe, which I’m sure resulted in some poor copyeditor being thrown into the charming Skylands dungeon), so they were untransportable anyway.

I brought some popsicles to the party and swore never to craft-bake again. None of this fussy, fiddly stuff. Let’s get some rustic cornmeal cakes in the July issue next time, you know, like the colonials (probably?) made (I guess?). Let’s bake like Americans, Martha. Come on.



  1. Come on Martha – is right!

    I created these disgusting bloody messes over a long frustrating day with my mom and sister. It only took five hours to create what is now the worst day in baking history our crafty family has ever experienced – ever.
    our last name is baker.
    so there you go. being able to bake is in our freak’n DNA, we probably were making those rustic cornmeal cakes – or what ever – centuries ago. What we weren’t doing was agonizing over runny icing (no too thick, no back to runny) and excitedly trailing toothpicks through bloody icing and what ended up being unappetizing blue. So unappetizing in fact, that it was a miracle my sister didn’t choke on that cardboard poker chip when barfing it up a few hours after digestion yep. it happened. EVEN her stomach rejected the unpatriotic bs.

    I’m convinced the cookies on the cover were created with an edible printer because – come on! Really?

    Best post ever!

  2. Sherice · September 8, 2011

    Dowes cookies are dope yo!

  3. Barbara Howson (Mom) · October 7, 2011

    This is the reason I don’t bake pinwheel cookies anymore for Christmas, or anytime.
    Too frustrating…when of course you are baking cookies to get that warm, fuzzy feeling of doing something in the kitchen that will make everyone happy…and it turns out that if the cook isn’t happy, no one is! Particularly when they are wearing particles of chocolate and vanilla cooky dough which you lobbed over to them when they cheerily asked “Any samples?”

  4. Pingback: Deny fall with a delicious zucchini cake « Marthable

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s